Law Firms Under Cyber Threat: Attacks, Fraud & Digital Evidence | Cyooda

Welcome to the Cybersecurity Loop #24

Law Firms Are Becoming ATMs for Cybercriminals. Here's Why.

It's been a few months since the last edition, and the threat picture hasn't stood still.

Three global law firms made cyber headlines this week. CrowdStrike has published figures showing just how aggressively criminals are targeting the legal sector. Australia's Essential Eight is evolving. And a familiar type of payment redirection fraud raises an important question: does knowing the details of a transaction prove someone hacked your email?

Here's what matters.

🔐 4 things law firm leaders should know right now:

1. CrowdStrike puts numbers on it: law firms are valuable targets.

CrowdStrike's 2026 Legal Threat Landscape Report makes uncomfortable reading. Financially motivated criminals accounted for 82% of observed malicious activity targeting the legal sector. Criminal leak sites named 455 legal entities, up 39% on the previous reporting period.

Australia is among the countries being targeted, with criminals advertising access to compromised legal networks.

One group, CHATTY SPIDER, increased its activity against legal entities by 129%. In one intrusion, the group attempted to steal data just four minutes after gaining access. In another, it recruited someone to pose as IT staff and physically enter a law firm's office.

Four minutes. That's barely enough time to report something suspicious, let alone investigate and contain an intrusion.

The Cyooda view: Criminals aren't necessarily interested in how much money your firm makes. They're interested in the confidential information you hold, the transactions you facilitate and the clients you represent.

A small conveyancing practice handling a valuable transaction can be just as attractive as a global firm advising on a merger.

Ask your IT provider: If someone gained access to our systems today, how quickly would we know, and how have we tested that?

Source: CrowdStrike — 2026 Legal Threat Landscape Report

2. Three global law firms. Three different cyber exposures.

On 17 November, The Lawyer reported that Clifford Chance had suffered a cyberattack. The firm declined to comment, leaving the extent of any compromise unclear.

The same day, Legal IT Insider reported that A&O Shearman had appeared on an alleged ransomware victim list. That claim remains unverified. A criminal group's listing is not, by itself, evidence of a successful attack.

Separately, Freshfields was identified among organisations affected by malicious code distributed through the Optimizely web platform. This was a third-party website supply-chain incident, not evidence that Freshfields' internal network had been breached.

Three different situations, with different levels of confirmation. But they illustrate the range of exposure law firms face: direct attacks, alleged data-theft extortion and compromise through trusted technology suppliers.

The Cyooda view: You can outsource your IT, but you cannot outsource accountability for your firm's information.

An IT provider might manage your Microsoft 365 environment while having no visibility of vulnerabilities in your website, practice management platform or other third-party services. Those gaps matter when confidential information is involved.

And if global firms with substantial security budgets face these risks, being a smaller practice is no reason to assume you're safe.

Ask your managing partner: Who is responsible for the cyber risks that sit outside our IT provider's contract?

Sources: Legal IT Insider / City AM / Report URI

3. The Essential Eight is evolving. A maturity score will no longer tell the whole story.

On 15 October, the Australian Signals Directorate launched ASD Essentials, building on the widely adopted Essential Eight.

The new approach is broader. Initial guidance covers enterprise IT, cloud and operational technology. It also considers areas such as governance, supplier security, detection and response.

One important change is how security posture is assessed.

Rather than relying on a single overall Essential Eight maturity level, ASD Essentials assesses security measures across individual domains, with an emphasis on evidence that they are effective.

The Essential Eight remains supported during the transition. Existing investment in those controls is not wasted, and there is no need to abandon current assessments.

The Cyooda view: I've never been particularly comfortable with reducing an organisation's cybersecurity posture to a single maturity score.

A firm might have MFA, endpoint protection, backups and documented policies. That's encouraging. But are those controls working? Are they applied consistently? Has anyone independently tested them?

Having a control and knowing it works are two different things.

For managing partners, the important question isn't what maturity level your IT provider says you've achieved.

It's which controls are effective, which have gaps, and what evidence supports those conclusions.

Source: Australian Signals Directorate — ASD Essentials

4. A fraudulent email doesn't necessarily mean your mailbox was hacked.

Consider a familiar scenario.

A client receives an email apparently from their solicitor, asking them to transfer money to a different bank account. The message refers to the correct property transaction, identifies the people involved and arrives at precisely the right time.

The client pays. The money disappears.

The immediate assumption? Someone must have compromised the solicitor's email account.

But that isn't necessarily what happened.

In a business email compromise investigation, one of the first questions is what the fraudster knew, and when they knew it.

Did they have access to an existing email conversation? Were they impersonating the solicitor using a lookalike address? Did the information come from the client's mailbox, another party to the transaction or somewhere else entirely?

Email headers, message timestamps, sign-in records and other digital evidence can help reconstruct the sequence.

Sometimes that evidence establishes a compromised account. Sometimes it points elsewhere. And sometimes it simply isn't sufficient to reach a definitive conclusion.

The Cyooda view: Knowing the details of a transaction does not prove a particular email account was compromised.

That distinction matters. A mistaken assumption about where a fraud originated can affect liability, insurance coverage and the advice a solicitor gives their client.

The first priority should be preserving the evidence, not deciding who is responsible.

Ask your firm: If a client reported a fraudulent payment instruction tomorrow, would we know what evidence to preserve before it disappears?


🔧 Tool: Have I Been Pwned

Have I Been Pwned is a useful way to check whether an email address has appeared in a known data breach.

Individual email searches are free. Organisations can also verify ownership of their email domain and monitor exposure, although full domain search capabilities may require a paid subscription.

A result doesn't mean an account is currently compromised, and no result doesn't mean it's secure. But it's a useful starting point for identifying credentials and accounts that deserve attention.

Ask your IT provider whether your firm's email domain is monitored for known breaches and what action follows an alert.

→ haveibeenpwned.com

💡 Tip: An IT badge is not proof of identity.

CrowdStrike has documented criminals impersonating IT support staff, including an attempt to gain physical access to a law firm's systems.

The rule should be simple: nobody claiming to be from IT, a vendor or a contractor gets access to a device unless their identity and reason for attending have been independently verified.

A uniform, badge or ticket number isn't enough. Reception should confirm the request through an established contact using a number already held by the firm, not one supplied by the visitor.

And ask your IT provider whether unauthorised removable storage is blocked by default.

Make sure reception, PAs and office managers know the procedure. They're often the first people an impersonator will approach.

📖 Resource: ASD Essentials — a guide for senior executives

ASD has published guidance specifically for senior executives explaining the new Essentials framework and how organisations should approach their cyber resilience.

It covers what leadership should understand about priorities, implementation and assessing whether security measures are actually working.

You don't need to become a technical expert to read it. But you should understand what your firm is measuring, who's accountable and how the results are being verified.

→ ASD — The Essentials for Senior Executives

💬 Quote

"Knowing what happened and proving what happened are two very different things."

— John Reeman, Cyooda Security


The common thread across these four stories isn't simply that cybercriminals are becoming more sophisticated.

It's that assumptions can be expensive.

Assuming your IT provider covers every risk. Assuming a security control works because it's been installed. Assuming a fraudulent email proves a mailbox was compromised.

When something goes wrong, it's the evidence that matters.

If your firm needs an independent view of its cybersecurity, or you're handling a matter where digital evidence needs to be preserved, examined or explained, I'm always happy to have a conversation.

Book a Cyber Chat

John Reeman
Founder & Principal Consultant
Cyooda Security

Digital Forensics | Incident Response | Cybersecurity | Expert Witness

#lawfirms #cybersecurity #digitalforensics #incidentresponse

John Reeman - Virtual CISO

John Reeman

I'm the CEO and Founder of Cyooda Security, an independent cybersecurity and digital forensics advisory consultancy based in Sydney. The former CISO of King & Wood Mallesons a global law firm, with 30 years of cybersecurity leadership, protecting organisations and government agencies from data breaches, ransomware, and cyber espionage.

The Legal Cyber Brief — What happened, what it means for your firm, and one question worth asking. Every month.

The Legal Cyber Brief
What happened, what it means for your firm, and one question worth asking. Every month.
First Name

The Legal Cyber Brief — Cyber risk for law firms, monthly.

The Legal Cyber Brief
What happened, what it means for your firm, and one question worth asking. Every month.
First Name